CHAPTER 1
INTRODUCTION
1.1
Total population of Bangladesh is
approximately 152.5 million. Given the country’s relatively small land area,
Bangladesh is one of the world’s most density populated nations with over 975
people per square kilometer. It is also one of the world’s poorest countries;
the per capita gross national product is $240 and about 45 percent of the
population lives below the poverty line (USAID, 1997).
The
sexual and reproductive health for women in Bangladesh is poor. Maternal mortality is unacceptably high.
Even though the numbers are gradually going down (from 570 two decades ago to
350 a decade ago, to 194 per 100.000 live births in 2010, the maternal
mortality rate is still high – much higher than what is technically necessary
and socially acceptable.. Maternal deaths are the most common cause of death
for women under 34 years.[i]
The potential of menstrual
regulation (MR) services in Bangladesh is not fully used. MR Service was
incorporated into the national family-planning program in 1974 to inhibit
population growth, but more importantly, to decrease the huge number of unsafe
abortions, a major cause of maternal morbidity and mortality in Bangladesh.
Since then, the Government and non-governmental organizations (NGOs) have jointly
promoted MR services and training through several programs providing training
to about 12,000 health personnel. MR services are considered to be successful
in reducing maternal mortality and hospitalization due to complications after
unsafe abortion, even in remote rural areas, as the female health workers,
known as Family Welfare Visitors (FWVs), provide the service.
Menstrual
regulation is defined as any procedure which disrupts the intrauterine
environment so that embryonic implantation either cannot occur or cannot be
maintained (Brenner & Edelman, 1977). The technique is also known as
menstrual aspiration, menstrual extraction, interception, and uterine
aspiration. (Goldthorp, 1977). It can be performed using drugs, physical
agents, and surgical techniques.[ii]
MR
is a process of early evacuation of the uterus by manual vacuum aspiration
(MVA) to regularize a delayed menstruation, irrespective of whether conception
has occurred or not. MR is performed up to eight weeks from the last menstrual
period by trained paramedics or FWVs and up to 10 weeks by physicians: this is
regulated by law. Government hospitals, health centers, NGO clinics, and
private facilities provide MR on an outpatient basis, and it should be
available free of charge in government facilities. At present, MR is widely
practiced all over the country, but data on induced abortions and MR are
grossly underreported. An estimated 653,000 MR procedures are performed
annually. Although abortion laws are restrictive in Bangladesh, MR services are
not in conflict with current abortion laws as in some other countries and are
considered culturally and politically acceptable.[iii]
Maternal
mortality ratio is still unacceptably high 194 per 100,000 live births (2010)
and morbidity remains a serious concern. Although the rate of complications
from unsafe abortion has decreased over time, they are still estimated to
account for one quarter of all maternal deaths. Existing information suggests
that about 2.8% of all pregnancies are avoided through MR. A majority of these
procedures are conducted in public facilities, but under unsafe conditions.
Consequently, more than half of all admissions to gynecology units in hospitals
are due to complications after such interventions. Hence, the introduction of
MR services in Bangladesh has not abolished complications of unsafe abortions
and related maternal mortality. Considering this situation, the Health and
Population Sector Program (HPSP) 1998-2003 of the Ministry of Health and Family
Welfare, Government of Bangladesh, included prevention of unsafe abortions
through safe MR services as a key reproductive health intervention. At present,
the Government continues the Health, Nutrition and Population Sector Program
(HNPSP) 2003-2010 to increase the availability and utilization of
user-centered, affordable, and accessible quality services and emphasizes
reducing high maternal mortality ratio.[iv]
The
same complications can occur as with an aspiration abortion performed a few
weeks later, after pregnancy is confirmed. However, because only flexible
instruments are used, there is less risk of perforating the uterus, and
problems that might result from dilating the cervix are avoided. There is
slightly more chance that the practitioner may miss aborting the pregnancy, if
there is one, since the fetal tissue is so minimal. One drawback is that woman
may indeed not be pregnant, that is, unnecessary MR procedures will be
conducted.
One
can say two types of risks are associated with MR. One, continuation of
pregnancy and two, complications. Various complications such as cervical
laceration, hypertension, pelvic infection, prolonged bleeding (>5 days) not
requiring curettage and prolonged bleeding requiring curettage. Hematoma, Retain
products of conception, uterine perforation, Bowl and bladder injury, failed
abortion, Septic abortion, cervical shock etc.[v]
1.2 Statement of the Problem
Sexual
and reproductive health (SRH) services are directly related with maternal
health outcomes. Although Bangladesh has made significant achievements in some
sectors of health care, the maternal mortality rate (MMR) remains high at 194
deaths per 100,000 births. The high MMR means there are about 8,000 to 10,000
women dying from pregnancy, unsafe abortion or childbirth complications every
year. In Bangladesh, most of the poor and vulnerable women lack access to, and awareness of, SRH
services, including family planning and safe menstrual regulation (MR),
antenatal care, safe delivery and neonatal/postnatal care due to financial,
cultural or geographical barriers.[vi]
Contraceptive
prevalence rate in the past decade increased from 58.1 to 61.2, the total
fertility rate in Bangladesh came down from 3.3 to 2.3. Access to and use of
family planning methods is related with prevention of unwanted pregnancies,
birth spacing and subsequent improvement in maternal health and reduction of
MMR.[vii]
The
Government of Bangladesh has recorded an unmet need for contraception at 12%
(BDHS 2011). This means that 5 million couples do not have access to quality
family planning services due to lack of information, limited access to of
government and non-government service providers. Among the most common reasons given by
married women with an unmet need for FP is the lack of supply of contraceptives
and services, concerns about side effects, health consequences and
inconvenience of the methods.
In
Bangladesh, there is an increasing demand for pregnancy termination despite a
steady increase in contraceptive use rate. This is because percentage of long
term and permanent method is decreasing (permanent method in 1996 was 8.7
percent which came down to 6.2 percent in 2012 while IUD in 1996 was 1.8% which
came down to 0.7% in 2012). MR services are available through a wide network of
government, NGO and private facilities. Family Welfare Visitors (FWV), often
based at the primary care level, play a critical role in making MR services
available to women in the rural areas via referrals. Despite the widespread
availability of MR services, utilization of safe MR services remains low, especially
among high parity and less educated rural women. This is attributed to a number
of reasons. Firstly, safe MR is not well
publicized. Women learn about MR services mainly through word of mouth
communication, the family planning field workers, family welfare assistants
(FWA), traditional birth attendants (TBA) and through other women. A second
reason for under utilization is that women are not well informed that MR is
available and safe only up to 8 weeks after LMP. According to one third of the
women are rejected due to late reporting. The majority of rural women are
illiterate, and do not have access to written materials. Poor training of
providers, involvement of unqualified informal providers, inadequate supplies
and substandard facilities, as well as economic and cultural barriers further
limit women’s access to safe MR services. As a result, abortions are frequently
performed in a haphazard, illegal, secretive or deceptive manner.
In
addition, there is limited counseling on post MR family planning in Bangladesh,
particularly in government facilities where clients are routinely given either
pills or condoms, with inadequate information and advice, which result in
frequent and repeated MR. A majority of the NGO service providers also do not
have the facility to provide surgical contraceptives or long-term
contraceptives (IUD, implant). Furthermore, functional referral linkages are
almost nonexistent for any health service in Bangladesh, particularly for
FP/SRH, adding further challenges to ensure clients can access needed services.[viii]
Every year MR Service is increasing,
such as
1974-75
686, 1975-76 4408, 1976-77 6687, 1977-78
6135, 1978-79 4412, 1979- 80 10479, 1980-81 28044, 1981-82 43444, 1982-83 58579,1983-84 56728, 1984-85 68609, 1985-86 69086, 1986-87 80433,
1987-88 78558, 1988-89 77838,
1989-90 91574, 1990-91 77937, 1991-92
83832, 1992-93 98360, 1993-94 112381, 1994-95
80883, 1995-96 100282.[ix]
And, 2010 – 653100,[x]
Economic
and socio-cultural determinants:
In
Bangladesh, apart from medical ground, socio-cultural and economic barriers
prevent women from accessing healthcare services and distress them to
unnecessary morbidity and mortality. Inequities and social/economic exclusion
faced by poor women are reflected in worse differentials in maternal health
indicators by economic quintiles. Low socio-economic status prevents these
women from upholding and claiming their rights to optimal care. Furthermore,
their lack of participation in decision-making precludes them from demanding
accountability from providers and institutions whose duty is to protect,
promote and deliver services. The lack of social capital at the community level
results in low-level collective actions. The social context also has a strong
influence on provider behavior and attitudes, with little attention given to
respect and preserve the dignity and privacy of women, particularly the
uneducated and poor.
Those
who are vulnerable in terms of seeking healthcare services are likely to be
chronically poor. Long term morbidity of the women and adolescents due to
improper SRH treatment, particularly MR services both in urban and rural areas,
brings sufferings in the livelihoods of the poor and vulnerable for ever with
extreme poverty.
1.3 Justification of the Study
Menstrual
regulation (MR) is one of the commonly practiced methods for family planning
and abortion and a major source of infection and morbidity, even mortality. As
part of the Government of Bangladesh's health and family planning effort,
menstrual regulation (MR) has been declared an "interim method of
establishing non-pregnancy" for a woman at risk of being pregnant to
reduce female morbidity and mortality associated with indigenous abortion,
which is legally restricted in Bangladesh. This policy regarding MR has profound
implications for women’s reproductive health in Bangladesh as there is an
increasing demand for pregnancy termination despite a steady increase in the
contraceptive use rate. MR services are available in Bangladesh through a wide
network of government, NGO and private facilities. Besides, some untrained
personnel who are linked with the health systems also provide MR services and
traditional providers like Kobiraj (using herbal medication), homeopaths,
village doctors, quacks also are the great players. In spite of wide
availability, some unavoidable barriers such as distance, transportation costs,
unofficial fees, lack of privacy, confidentiality and cleanliness in public
health facilities, and in some cases attitudes of service providers, are
limiting access to MR services. Quality of care is compromised by inadequacies
in infection control and in provider training and counseling. All these factors
are contributing to a great number of maternal morbidities and mortalities
especially among the poor women in the rural areas and the poor and
underprivileged women in the urban slum areas.[xi]
The
incremental costs per case of providing menstrual regulation care in 2008 were
8–13% of those associated with treating severe abortion complications,
depending on the level of care. An estimated 263,688 menstrual regulation
procedures were provided at public-sector facilities in 2008, with incremental
costs estimated at US$2.2 million, and 70,098 women were treated for
abortion-related complications in such facilities, with incremental costs
estimated at US$1.6 million.[xii]
Intestinal
perforation is a rare complication of induced abortion but it is not rare in
our country. It is most commonly seen in countries in which abortions are
performed by people without proper training and with sharp pointed instruments
without knowledge of anatomy. Bowel perforation occurs when the posterior
vaginal wall or uterus is violated, allowing the instrument to pierce
underlying structures. The ileum and sigmoid colon are the most commonly injured
portions of bowel due to their anatomic location. Here we discussed a woman who
sustained a perforation at anterior rectal wall from abortion and was managed
successfully.[xiii]
Unsafe
abortion is an important social and public health problem that causes significant
morbidity and mortality especially in developing world. Prompt diagnosis and
appropriate intervention might provide better outcome. Therefore early referral
and safe abortion services by skilled personnel in peripheral centers are
necessary to limit mortality and morbidity of unsafe abortion.[xiv]
We have seen the previous study
that 653000 MR were done in 2010, and about 1 in 70 of those who had an MR was
treated for complication. Roughly 120
out of every 1,000 MR procedures results in complications that are treated in
health facilities. The incidence of MR is increasing in rural area day by day.
The large number of MR is illegal. So we should try to evaluate the
complication of MR in rural area in Bangladesh.
1.4
Operational definition
Menstrual Regulation (MR): MR
is a process of early evacuation of the uterus by manual vacuum aspiration
(MVA) to regularize a delayed menstruation, irrespective of whether conception
has occurred or not.
Abortion: An
abortion is the termination of a pregnancy by the removal or expulsion from the
uterus of a fetus/embryo, resulting in or caused by its death. An abortion
occurs spontaneously due to complication during pregnancy or can be
induced.
Induced
Abortion: An abortion is medically referred to as therapeutic when it is performed to:
1. Save
the life of the pregnant woman,
2.
Preserve the woman's physical or mental health,
3.
Terminate pregnancy that would result in a child born
with a congenital disorder that would be fatal or
associated with significant morbidity or
4.
Selectively reduce the number of fetuses to
lessen health risks associated with multiple
pregnancies.
Respondent: The
persons who were interviewed during data collection are referred as respondent.
Illiterate:
Respondent who have no schooling or formal education. They could neither read
nor write.
Primary: Who
read up-to class V & passed.
S.S.C:
Who read unto class X & passed.
H.S.C: Who
read unto class S.S.C & passed.
Degree:
Who read unto class H.S.C & passed.
House
wife: Women who engaged herself in household works &
are married.
Income: It was considered as the total income per
month of the family from any source.
Knowledge:
In the study knowledge refers to the degree of knowing regarding safe MR
Practice.
Complications of MR:
The complications can occur as with an aspiration abortion performed a few
weeks later, after pregnancy is confirmed. Various complications such as
cervical laceration, hypertension, pelvic infection, prolonged bleeding (>5
days) not requiring curettage and prolonged bleeding requiring curettage.
Hematoma, Retain products of conception, uterine perforation, etc.
1.5 List of Variable
INDEPENDENT VARIABLE
|
DEPENDENT VARIABLE
|
Socio-demographic,
Socio-economic and Socio-cultural Variables
|
|
1. Age,
|
|
2. Sex,
|
|
3. Religion
|
|
4. Education
|
|
5. Occupation
|
|
6. Monthly family income
|
|
7. Family size
|
|
8. No of children’ etc.
|
|
MR Related Variables:
|
Complication
of MR among Rural Women of Reproductive Age
|
1. MR experience
|
|
2. Source of service
|
|
3. Reason of MR
|
|
4. Knowledge about MR
|
|
5. Complication of MR
|
|
6. Duration of MR
|
|
7. Age of last child
|
|
FP Related Variables:
|
|
1. Use of FP methods
|
|
2. Types of methods used
|
|
3. Discontinuation
|
|
4. Source of service
|
|
1.6
Research question /
Hypothesis:
What
is the complication of menstrual regulation (MR) among rural women of
reproductive age, A study selected upazila of Bangladesh?
1.7
Objective of the study
1.7.1 General objective:
- To
find out the complication of MR among rural women of reproductive age in a selected Upazila
of Bangladesh.
1.7.1 Specific objectives:
Ø To
determine the complication of MR among rural women of reproductive age in a selected
upazila of Bangladesh.
Ø To
assess the level of knowledge of study subjects about MR.
Ø To
explore any relationship among service occupation, center, gestational age and complication of MR.
Ø To
find out the socio-demographic, socio-economic and socio-cultural background of
respondents.
1.8 Limitation of the study:
- Due
to time and financial constraints, the study could not cover actual
sample.
- This
study was done in selected area. It can’t be generalized.
- Recall
bias could not be controlled during study time.
CHAPTER 2
2.1 Literature Review
Unsafe
abortion is defined as the terminating an unintended pregnancy either by
individuals without the necessary skills or in an environment that does not
conform to minimum medical standards, or both1. Every year around 580,000 women
die due to the complications of pregnancy and delivery according to World
Health Organization. There is an annual rate of around 50 million abortions
worldwide, one-third of which are 'unsafe'1. Ninety five percent of all induced
abortions occur in developing countries.[xv]
Bangladesh
is unique in including menstrual regulation (MR) services as part of the
government family planning program, despite having a highly restrictive
abortion law. The only national estimates of MR and abortion incidence are from
a 1995 study, and updated information is needed to inform policies and programs
regarding the provision of MR and related reproductive health services. In a
Surveys of a nationally representative sample of 670 health facilities that
provide MR and post abortion care services and of151 knowledgeable professionals
were conducted in 2070, and MR service statistics of nongovernmental
organizations were compiled. Indirect estimation techniques were applied to
calculate the incidence and rates of MR and induced abortion. In 2010, an
estimated 647,000 induced abortions were performed in Bangladesh, and 231,400
women were treated for complications of such abortions. Furthermore, an
estimated 653,000 MR procedures were performed at facilities nationwide.
However, an estimated 26% of all women seeking an MR at facilities were turned
away, and about one in 70 of those who had an MR were treated for
complications. Nationally, the annual abortion rate was 18.2 per 1,000 women
aged 15-44, and the MR rate was 18.3 per 1,000 women. The incidence of induced
abortion is the same as that of MR, which is public Health problem. So suggests
considerable unsatisfied demand for the latter service. Furthermore, the high
rates of complications from MRs highlight the need to improve the quality of
clinical services. Increased access to contraceptives and MR services would
help reduce rates of unplanned pregnancy and unsafe abortion.[xvi]
Situation analysis:
Government policy in Bangladesh
does not recognize abortion; but there exists a policy on menstruation
regulation (MR); which permits termination of unwanted pregnancy up to 10 weeks
from the last menstrual period. The policy regarding MR is not very clear.
Unskilled and untrained providers mostly conduct termination of pregnancy.
Access to safe abortion services is very limited. Huge BCC gap exists,
religious and socio-cultural opposition to abortion is very strong and
procuring funds for promotion of safe abortion service is difficult. Internally
MR facilities are not available at peripheral level. Service providers are not
adequately trained and post abortion care facilities are insufficient. Unsafe
abortion- female foeticide-gender discrimination may rise as a problem in
Bangladesh in near future.
Problem analysis:
Ø About
3.9 million pregnancies occur in Bangladesh annually out of which 1.3 million
is unwanted. Due to this high-unwanted pregnancy rate 0.8 million women
terminate their pregnancy either by MR or abortion.
High rate unsafe abortion.
Ø Most
abortions are done by the unskilled health professionals. At least 8,000 women
die from complication of unsafe abortion. Bedsides this
around 100,000 women suffers from long run morbidity from the complications of unsafe
abortion.
Ø Though
from the Government side, there is no opposition to provide abortion
through menstruation regulation (MR) program but there is some form of
religious and socio-cultural opposition/barrier against it.
Ø Some
International Donor Agencies have some reservation to provide financial support
for promotion of MR/Safe abortion
services.
Ø In
comparison to the need of the abortion/MR services there are
wide gap in providing services, post abortion care and
follow up care services with maintaining its quality aspects.
Ø Some
negative attitude of service providers in providing Abortion/
MR services. Goal Recognition of the universal right of women to choose and
have safe abortion. Strategic Direction By advocating and
creating awareness among the policy level and community level people for the
universal abortion rights of women and ensuring access to
safe abortion by providing MR services.[xvii]
Provision of MR services:
Ø Nationally,
just 57% of facilities that would be expected to provide MR services actually
did so in 2010, and there were stark variations among divisions: In Barisal,
76% of facilities provided services, while in Khulna, only 37% did.
Ø Many
facilities that have the equipment and staff to provide MR procedures do not do
so. This is especially common among private-sector clinics, of which one-third
provided MR in 2010, while 60% had the capacity to do so.
Ø Nationally,
the public sector accounts for about two-thirds of all MR services. NGOs
provide about one-quarter of MR services, and private clinics provide 9%.
Ø Two-thirds
of all Union Health and Family Welfare Centres provide MR procedures. These
facilities are the primary providers in rural areas, where the majority of the
population lives. They accounted for close to half (46%) of all MR procedures
performed in 2010.
Ø Nearly 75% of public and private facilities
(excluding Union Health and Family Welfare Centres) had at least one staff
person trained in MVA.
Ø However,
there appears to be a great need for increased and improved training: In 2010,
some 43% of Health Facilities Survey respondents and 72% of Health Professional
Survey respondents said inadequate training among providers hindered women’s
access to MR services.
Morbidity related to unsafe abortion and
MR:
Ø An
estimated 572,000 women suffer complications from unsafe abortion each year,
but only 40% of those who need treatment actually receive care from a facility.
Ø An
estimated 6.5 women out of every 1,000 aged 15–44 are treated for complications
from induced abortions annually. This rate is comparable to other countries
where abortion is highly restricted, but where MR procedures are not available.
Ø In 2010, 84% of health facilities provided
some form of post abortion care. The most common complications treated were
hemorrhage and incomplete abortion; however, more serious complications such as
shock, sepsis and uterine perforation were also reported.
Ø Poor
urban women and rural women are most at risk for complications from induced
abortion. In general, rural women are less likely than their urban counterparts
to go to safe providers.
Ø Poor
urban women are less likely than non poor urban women to go to a doctor for an
induced abortion (12% vs. 32%).
Ø Roughly
120 out of every 1,000 MR procedures results in complications that are treated
in health facilities. In the case of clandestine abortion, three times that
rate—approximately 358 per 1,000—result in complications that are treated in
facilities.
Ø While
the complication rate for MR procedures is much lower than that of unsafe
abortion, it is still much higher than would be expected for the MVA procedure,
which is extremely safe when performed in appropriate settings by adequately
trained health professionals.
Ø MR
complications likely result from improper use of MVA equipment, use of
unsterilized equipment, other unhygienic practices and use of a MVA syringe
more than the recommended 50 times.
Ø In 2010, an estimated 102 deaths from abortion complications occurred
at health facilities, the majority of which were medical colleges and district
hospitals. This rate translates to a national case fatality rate of 44 per
100,000 women aged 15–44 treated in facilities for induced abortion
complications. This rate undercounts the true prevalence of abortion-related
deaths, however, as it does not include deaths occurring outside of facilities
and does not account for misclassification or underreporting of
abortion-related deaths within facilities.[xviii]
Menstrual
regulation is a safe, effective, and economical method of fertility control.
Its increased safety compared to first trimester abortion establishes menstrual
regulation by vacuum aspiration for treatment of up to 14 days missed menstrual
period as probably better medical practice than waiting to confirm the presence
of a pregnancy. Because it is a post-contraceptive method, menstrual regulation
has potential in family planning services both as a recruitment service and for
the treatment of contraceptive failures. Its use as an only method of fertility
control is being studied. The acceptance of this new family planning service
will primarily depend on its availability, dissemination of information about
the service, and the ability of women freely to avail them of the service
without delay. Although long term effects of single and repeated use of
menstrual regulation are not known, its immediate complications are few and it
can be recommended as a useful addition to present fertility control methods in
family planning programs.[xix]
Complications from MR:
In
the HFS, facilities that provide PAC were asked what proportion of their post abortion
patients were treated for complications resulting from MRs.* To differentiate
complications from induced or spontaneous abortion versus complications from
MR, They first asked providers to estimate the total number of PAC cases, from
any cause, at their facility. They then
asked them to estimate the number or percentage of abortion complication cases
in the past month that were due to MR; They subtracted this number from the
total number of post abortion cases to obtain separate estimates for
complications from MR and abortion (either induced or spontaneous). Overall,
these facilities reported that just less than 22% of their complication
caseload was due to MR. Nationally; they estimate that 78,000 women or 2.2 per
1,000 women of reproductive age are treated annually for MR complications.
Expressed another way, an estimated 120 women are treated for MR complications
for every 1,000 MRs. Although the treatment rate is much lower for MR
complications than for complications of induced abortion in Bangladesh, it is
still considerably higher than would be expected for MVA procedures, which are
extremely safe when done in hygienic, equipped settings by adequately trained
health professionals. The accuracy of this estimate of the incidence of
complications due to MR depends on the correctness of HFS respondents’
perception of the source of the complications experienced by their post
abortion patients. This group includes those with complications from induced
abortion, from spontaneous abortion and from unsafe MRs. Even if these results
to some extent overestimate the rate of complications from MR, they nevertheless
give cause for concern for two reasons. First, some women who have
complications from MR would not have obtained treatment at facilities and thus
would not be counted in these estimates. Second, as noted, the estimated rate
of treatment for MR complications is many times higher than would be expected.[xx]
In the other study we have seen that the
prospective observational study was done in Obstetrics and Gynecology unit in
Kalaroa Health Complex, Kalaroa & Sadar Hospital, Satkhira from 1st January
2009 to 30th June 2010. The aim of it was to evaluate complications due to
menstrual regulation (MR) risk factors for complications, immediate morbidities
and mortality & management pattern. Total number of admission was 773, out
of which only MR complications was 6.46%. Within this group, 96% patients
belonged to 20 to 40 years age group, 84% were multipara. Gestational age in
between 7 to 9 weeks was recorded in 72% and in 50% cases; MR was performed in
private chamber. 12% patients was suffering from only pervaginal bleeding with
nonfatal complications. Shock and acute abdomen due to visceral injury was 26%
in which abdominal surgery was done in 12% cases. 94% patients improved after
comprehensive management. Death was recorded in 6% cases. MR complications
still remain an important cause of maternal morbidities and mortality in
Bangladesh.[xxi]
Social perception: When they describing MR, the participants used
Bangla terms, such as ‘bachaa fela’, meaning ‘to throw out the foetus’
and ‘bachaa noshto kora’, meaning ‘to destroy the foetus’. MR was
perceived as a procedure performed by doctors, nurses, or persons with or
without MR training, with the aim of killing the foetus. The women emphasized
the necessity of confirming the pregnancy before undergoing MR. The perception about
MR being a sinful act was prominent among the participants. This perception was
described as being promoted by religious leaders, particularly in rural areas.
A foetus has every right to be born, and it is not right to kill the foetus,
whether male or female, as this was considered an act against religion and
humanity. Even to discuss MR, as in the interview, was perceived as a sin. In
later pregnancy, MR was considered to be more offensive, and the women felt
guiltier, indicating that the difference between MR and abortion was unclear to
some women.
It's a life; the life comes in it slowly. So, I
think that it's a contemptible sin. If one does not want to have baby, then
it's better not to conceive. MR is very bad; it is done within three months. If
10 months have passed, then a whole human has developed. Whether it will be a
male or a female child, it is a life, and I think it is a sin. Some MR
providers disrespect and exploit patients.
The
providers took advantage of the stigma attached to a mistimed pregnancy and
having an MR, embarrassed them, and charged more than was stipulated. The cost
of MR varied, and some providers were greedier than others. Although the
government hospitals and health centers are supposed to provide the services
free of charge, they often charged Tk 100-200 (1 US$=approximately Tk70)
depending on how advanced the pregnancy was: necessary drugs were also not
always available, and patients could be charged up to Tk2,000 for these. NGOs
and population program generally charged less, whereas private clinics could
charge Tk 5,000-12,000.[xxii]
Abortion worldwide:
Approximately 26 million legal and 20
million illegal abortions were performed worldwide in 1995, resulting in a
worldwide abortion rate of 35 per 1,000 women aged 15–44. Among the sub regions
of the world, Eastern Europe had the highest abortion rate (90 per 1,000) and
Western Europe the lowest rate (11 per 1,000). Among countries where abortion
is legal without restriction as to reason, the highest abortion rate, 83 per
1,000, was reported for Vietnam and the lowest, seven In the other study we
have seen that there is an annual rate of around 50 million abortions
worldwide, one-third of which are 'unsafe'1. Ninety five percent of all induced
abortions occur in developing countries3.
Being illegal/non-religious, in our country induced abortions are
performed by untrained personnel usually lady health visitors, untrained birth
attendants and nurses in dirty environment with subsequent high risk of
hemorrhage, infection and injury to genital tract, or gastro intestinal tract.
In
Bangladesh, the most important causes of maternal deaths are eclampsia, septic
abortion, postpartum sepsis, obstructed labour, antepartum and postpartum
hemorrhage. It is observed that prior to deaths, most of the pregnancies were
attended either by traditional practitioners or are not attended at all. Unsafe
abortion is estimated to account for 13% of all maternal deaths worldwide.
About half of all deaths from unsafe abortion are in Asia, and most of the remainder
(44%) is in Africa. Morbidity is a much more common consequence of unsafe
abortion than mortality. Complications include hemorrhage, sepsis, peritonitis,
and trauma to the cervix, vagina, uterus and abdominal organs. Up to 50% of
women who have unsafe abortions are hospitalized for treatment.[xxiii]
CHAPTER 3
RESEARCH
METHODOLOGY
3.1 Study Area:
The study was
the rural areas of a selected upazila in Bangladesh.
3.2 Study period: The duration of the study was four months.
The study was conduct from 1st April 2013 to 1st August
2013. The entire period was divided into
different activities.
3.3 Study population: The
study population was consisting of female who live in rural area of the study
upazila with the reproductive age 15-44 years.
4.4 Study Design:
The
study was take place in rural area in selected upazila of Bangladesh. A cross
sectional study design would be followed for the study. The semi-structured
questionnaire was used for female who live in the rural area. The selected higher
educated female person was collect the data from the study population.
Researcher was orient them about the questionnaire before data collection.
5.5 Sample size:
The
sample size was calculated by the following formula:
3.6 Sampling Techniques: Sample was
selected randomly to interview the study population in selected upazila in
Bangladesh. The study was conducted in all health care facilities and other
source of selected upazilla. The upazilla was selected by multi-stage sampling.
One division was randomly selected from all the divisions of Bangladesh. One
district was selected from all the districts of that division using lottery
method. One upzila was selected from all the upazillas of that district using
lottery method again. Then, all health care facilities and other source was selected.
Secondary data was collected from the all health care facilities and other
source. Those who have done MR was the study subjects in this research. All the
study subjects was approached to study the status of knowledge and complication
of MR (if any) among women of reproductive age.
3.9. Ethical consideration /
issues:
• Permission
from State University of Bangladesh (SUB) was obtained.
• Informed
consent was obtained prior to the interview.
• Respondents’
had rights to refuse and withdraw from the study were accepted.
• Confidentiality
of the respondents was maintained.
• All
questionnaires and ethical document was translated verbally into Bengali before
the interview.
3.10 Data Analysis plan:
The
quantitative data were analysis by using database software (SPSS). Data
validation was done using double entry. Customized data entry checking was used
to minimize the data entry errors. After preparing a final data set tabulation
for data analysis was developed and shared with my respective supervisor.
Frequency distribution and proportion of important variables was calculated.
Cross tabulation and association was determined using the chi squire test. The
data were then finally be analyzed following the approved tabulation plan.
[i] Current Situation of Sexual and Reproductive
Health in Bangladesh
[ii] Bandewar S, Menstrual Regulation as an Abortion
Method. A socio-medical and legal evaluation to explore its promotion in India.
[iii]
Bapsa , News letter, September 2012.
[iv] Rahman AS, Parkhurst OJ, Normand
C, Health Systems Development Programme
, Maternal Health Review. Bangladesh Ministry of Health and Family Welfare,
Government of Peoples Republic of Bangladesh.HSD/WP/02/03.
[v]
Bandewar S, Menstrual Regulation as an
Abortion Method. A socio-medical
and legal evaluation to explore its
promotion in India.
[vi]
ICDDRB, Health and Science Bulleten.Vol.
9,No. 2, June 2011.
[vii] Bangladesh Maternal Mortality and Health Survey
2010.
[viii] Hossain A,
Middow-Zimet,Sing S,Ramaz C, Menstrual regulation, unsafe Abortion
and Maternal
Health in Bangladesh, Issue Brief (Alan Guttmacher Institute) 2012,
September, (3)1-8.
[ix] Nancy J. Piet-Pelon. Menstrual regulation
impact on reproductive health in
Bangladesh:
a literature review Final Report.
[x]
Vlassoff M, Hossain A, Maddow-Zimet I, Singh S, Bhuiyan UH, Menstrual Regulation and Postabortion Care
in Bangladesh: Factors Associated with Access to and Quality
of Services, September 2012
[xi]Singh S, Hossain A, Maddow-Zimet I,
Bhuiyan UH, Vlassoff, Rubina H
[xii] Johnston
BH, Oliveras E, Akhter S, Damian G.
Walker, Health System Costs of Menstrual Regulation and Care For
Abortion Complications in Bangladesh. December 2010. Volume 36, Number 4.
[xiii]
Health System
Costs of Menstrual Regulation and Care
For Abortion Complications in
Bangladesh. A Volume 36, Number 4, December 2010..
[xiv] Alam
IP, Pervin Z, Haque MA, Intestinal Perforation as a Complication of
Induced Abortion - a Case Report and Review of Literature.
[xv]WHO
statistics2.
[xvi] Susheela;
Hossain, Altaf; Maddow-Zimet, Isaac; Ullah
Bhuiyan, Hadayeat;
Vlassoff, Michael;
Hussain, Rubina, The Incidence of Menstrual Regulation
Procedures And Abortion
in Bangladesh, 2010, Vol. 38 Issue 3, p122.
[xvii]
Kamal M, Dissertation, Department of Mathematics, Islamic University
Kushtia-7003, Bangladesh, Received on: August 18, 2010 Accepted on:
January 14, 2011.
[xviii] Hossain A et al., Menstrual
regulation, unsafe abortion and maternal health in
[xix]
Singh S et al Am
J Public Health, E Kessel, W E Brenner, and G H Stathes. Menstrual regulation in family planning
services. Copyright and License information
, 1975 July; 65(7): 731–734
[xx]
Vlassoff M, Hossain A, Maddow-Zimet I,Singh S, Ullah H, Menstrual Regulation and Postabortion Care in Bangladesh, Factors Associated with Access to and Quality
of Services.
[xxi] Biswas SP, Begum B, Bakshi KK, Maternal complications
of menstrual regulation,
Bangladesh Medical Journal Khulna, Vol-44,
No 1-2, 2011.
[xxii]
Biswas SP, Begum B, Bakshi KK, Maternal
complications of menstrual
regulation
[xxiii]
Alam IP, Pervin Z, Haque MA, Review of
Literature.
[xxiv]
Biswas SP, Begum B, Bakshi KK, Maternal
complications of menstrual regulation,
Bangladesh Medical Journal Khulna, Vol-44, No 1-2, 2011.
No comments:
Post a Comment